Formulário de avaliação

1) Which of these groups do you belong to or represent?

ShareholderMarket analyst CustomerAcademia (student, professor, researcher) SuplliersGovernment representation PressVale employee/contractor NGO representative

Other (please specify)

2) Does this report help to clarify Vale's activities in the economic, environmental and social fields?   YesNoPartially

3) How would you rate this report based on the following characteristics: Clarity (is the language used easy to understand?)   YesNoPartially

Visual presentation (does the format used facilitate consultation?)   YesNoPartially

4) How would you rate the content of Vale's 2008 Sustainability Report?   ExcellentGoodRegularBad 5) From the list below, select the report's chapters that are most relevant to you. How would you evaluate these chapters?

Relevance Evaluation Yes No Excellent Good Regular Bad I don't know Profile    Message from the Board     Message from the President     Introduction and Reporting Process     Sustainability Strategy     Business Performance     Corporate Governance     Human Rights     Health and Safety     Environment     Local Development     Value Chain     Climate Change     Biodiversity     Human Rights

6) Did you read the previous report? If so, did you notice any improvements since the last one?  
YesNo
What progress did you perceive?  

7) Which themes deserve more detailed coverage in the next report?  

8) Is there any theme that should have been covered in this report, but was not?  

9) Having read this report, do you agree that Vale is a company that behaves in a socially and environmentally responsible way?  
I totally agree
I partially agree
I partially disagree
I totally disagree
10) To make additional comments about the 2008 Sustainability Report, use the space below.  

11) Identification and details for correspondence (optional)

Name
E-mail addresses
Address
City	CEP/zip code
Brazilian state/Federal District	Country